Skip to main content

The HST Facts vs Dan Lett, HST Defender

Oh for the good old days. You know, when you believed what you read in the newspapers because, well, if it wasn't true, they wouldn't print it, right?

Those were the days when you assumed reporters were "professionals" who researched their stories before writing them. Oh, and they had editors who made double sure everything was accurate and true. Right?

Then -- damn you Al Gore --- came the Internet.

And, suddenly, people could actually check the so-called "facts" in the newspaper for themselves. And, whoops, it appears the "professionals" were making up a whole lot of what they wrote, editors or no editors.

Enter Winnipeg Free Press columnist Dan Lett, who has taken to imagining himself a commentator on national issues.
His latest observations, headlined "Public's HST phobia needless" consisted of insulting people who opposed the blending of their provincial sales tax with the federal GST into one giant universal money-sucking tax.

"The debate over the HST is not intelligent or rational." he wrote. Got that? You anti-HST crusaders are stupid AND irrational.

To demonstrate his own smarts, Lett decided to give the fools a lesson in economics.
"And while there is short-term hit in the price of goods and services, ultimately it is believed prices will go down. A recent study by economists at the University of New Brunswick showed the introduction of the HST in Atlantic Canada in 1997 did result in savings for consumers."


"The HST, a revenue-neutral tax that ultimately has the potential to save consumers money, doesn't really deserve to be on that list. An intelligent debate would have revealed that."

Oh yeah?

Maybe Lett should have actually read the "recent study by economists at the University of New Brunswick" before citing it to bolster his argument. It's not hard to find --- on the Internet. We found it and read it, along with a subsequent report from the C.D. Howe Institute.on the consumer effects of the HST.

Both studies tried to determine if the adoption of the HST in Newfoundland, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia in 1997 reduced costs to consumers.

Now, not being university eggheads, we would have answered the question the same way you would --- we would have asked our mothers.

Mom, did prices go up or down after they brought in the HST?
Simple, eh. Obviously too simple.

How would academics do it? For the answer we turn to the study:
The Effect of the Harmonized Sales Tax on Consumer Prices in Atlantic Canada
Department of Economics
University of New Brunswick
Fredericton, New Brunswick
"Turning to our forecast procedure, we use the pre- HST data and Holt-Winters’ double exponential smoothing method with additive seasonal adjustments for generating forecasts for the logarithmic transformation of CPI (i.e., dependent variable = LnCPI) for the HST period. We then follow a counter-factual procedure by comparing the estimated LnCPI (denoted by Ln CPI ), in the absence of the HST, to the actual LnCPI to derive the impact of the HST on consumer prices as measured by (LnCPI – Ln CPI ), for each of the HST-participating provinces."

Okay, have you got that, or do we have to repeat it?

So after the proper smoothing, adjusting, estimating and applying the proper counter-factual procedure, the professors reached a conclusion.

"...overall, consumer prices fell given the new HST regime."
Well, actually, "... the overall price fell somewhat."

And, umm----you're going to laugh---the data doesn't actually prove a direct connection between the HST and the drop in prices, said the experts.

You see, in accepting the HST, the Maritime provinces chopped their provincial sales taxes significantly. Newfoundland dropped theirs from 12 percent to 8. The other two provinces cut theirs from 11 percent to 8.

So, umm, the fall in consumer prices might actually be due to the CUT IN RETAIL SALES TAX and not the benefits of the HST being passed through to consumers.
"Our results, in other words, cannot immediately be extended to consumers in other provinces. The three participating provinces had the highest sales tax rates in the country, and reducing those high tax rates to 8 percent (along with changing the tax bases) ended up benefiting consumers."
So cutting taxes results in lower prices. YOUR MOTHERS COULD HAVE TOLD YOU THAT.
Except that they couldn't detect the falling prices. For that we had to turn to the July, 2007, report from the C.D. Howe Institute:
Lessons in Harmony:
What Experience in the Atlantic
Provinces Shows About the
Benefits of a Harmonized Sales Tax

Author Michael Smart concluded "...overall, CPI prices fell by about 0.3 percent in HST provinces after 1997, compared to the corresponding change in RST provinces."

Got it? Prices in the HST provinces after two years were a gi-montrous three quarters of one percent less than prices in the other provinces with their own sales taxes. Well, whoop dee doo.

"This difference" wrote Michael Smart, " is statistically insignificant..." You don't need a PhD to know that, brother.

So, if the upside of the HST is so tiny to be essentially irrelevant, is there a downside? The experts opinions ranged from 'uh, maybe', to 'Yessiree Bob'.

Professors Murrell and Yu said their analysis didn't examine that possibility, although they concluded:

" could be the case that certain income groups, in particular, low-income families, might do worse given the move to harmonize sales taxes."

Michael Smart, however, did the math.

"Particularly notable, perhaps, are the estimated 1.4 percent price increase for Shelter, reflecting the extension of the tax base to include purchases of new houses, and 1.5 percent price increase for Clothing and Footwear, which also likely reflects the broader base of the HST. Since expenditure shares for these categories tend to be larger for low-income households, this suggests the possibility that the reform was regressive in that it raised average prices for low-income households while lowering prices overall."

"Thus I conclude that the HST reform had a mild regressive effect."
Or, as our mothers would say,"The poor get screwed."

Or is that not intelligent or rational enough for "professional" journalists to understand?

Popular posts from this blog

The unreported bombshell conspiracy evidence in the Trudeau/SNC-Lavelin scandal

Wow. No, double-wow. A game-changing bombshell lies buried in the supplementary evidence provided to the House of Commons Judiciary Committee by former Attorney General Jody Wilson-Raybould. It has gone virtually unreported since she submitted the material almost a week ago. As far as we can find, only one journalist-- Andrew Coyne, columnist for the National Post--- has even mentioned it and even then he badly missed what it meant, burying it in paragraph 10 of a 14 paragraph story. The gist of the greatest political scandal in modern Canadian history is well-known by now. It's bigger than Adscam, the revelation 15 years ago that prominent members of the Liberal Party of Canada and the party itself funneled tens of millions of dollars in kickbacks into their own pockets from federal spending in Quebec sponsoring ads promoting Canadian unity. That was just venal politicians and a crooked political party helping themselves to public money. The Trudeau-Snc-Lavalin scandal is

Crips and Bloodz true cultural anchors of Winnipeg's aboriginal gangs

(Bebo tribute page to Aaron Nabess on the right, his handgun-toting friend on the left) At least six murder victims in Winnipeg in the past year are linked to a network of thuglife, gangster rap-styled, mainly aboriginal street gangs calling themselves Crips and Bloods after the major black gangs of L.A. The Black Rod has been monitoring these gangs for several months ever since discovering memorial tributes to victim Josh Prince on numerous pages on, a social networking website like Myspace and Facebook. Josh Prince , a student of Kildonan East Collegiate, was stabbed to death the night of May 26 allegedly while breaking up a fight. His family said at the time he had once been associated with an unidentified gang, but had since broken away. But the devotion to Prince on sites like Watt Street Bloodz and Kingk Notorious Bloodz (King-K-BLOODZ4Life) shows that at the time of his death he was still accepted as one of their own. Our searches of Bebo have turned up another five ga

Manitoba Hydro is on its deathbed. There, we said it.

Manitoba Hydro is on its deathbed. Oh, you won't find anyone official to say it. Yet . Like relatives trying to appear cheery and optimistic around a loved one that's been diagnosed with terminal cancer, the people in power are in the first stage of grief -- denial. The prognosis for Hydro was delivered three weeks ago at hearings before the Public Utilities Board where the utility was seeking punishingly higher rates for customers in Manitoba. It took us this long to read through the hundred-plus pages of transcript, to decipher the coded language of the witnesses, to interpret what they were getting at, and, finally, to understand the terrible conclusion.  We couldn't believe it, just as, we're sure, you can't--- so we did it all again, to get a second opinion, so to speak.  Hydro conceded to the PUB that it undertook a massive expansion program--- involving three (it was once four) new dams and two new major powerlines (one in the United States)---whi

Nahanni Fontaine, the NDP's Christian-bashing, cop-smearing, other star candidate

As the vultures of the press circle over the wounded Liberal Party of Manitoba, one NDP star candidate must be laughing up her sleeve at how her extremist past has escaped the scrutiny of reporters and pundits. Parachuted into a safe NDP seat in Winnipeg's North End, she nonetheless feared a bruising campaign against a well-heeled Liberal opponent.  Ha ha.  Instead, the sleepy newspeeps have turned a blind eye to her years of vitriolic attacks on Christianity, white people, and police. * She's spent years  bashing Christianity  as the root cause of all the problems of native people in Canada. * She's called for  a boycott of white businesses . * And with her  Marxist research partner, she's  smeared city police as intransigent racists . Step up Nahanni Fontaine, running for election in St. John's riding as successor to the retiring Gord Macintosh. While her male counterpart in the NDP's galaxy of stars, Wab Kinew, has responded to the controversy over

Exposing the CBC/WFP double-team smear of a hero cop

Published since 2006 on territory ceded, released, surrendered and yielded up in 1871 to Her Majesty the Queen and successors forever. Exposing the CBC/FP double-team smear of a hero cop Some of the shoddiest journalism in recent times appeared this long August weekend when the CBC and Winnipeg Free Press doubled teamed on a blatant smear of a veteran city police officer. In the latest example of narrative journalism these media outlets spun stories with total disregard for facts that contradicted the central message of the reports which, simplified, is: police are bad and the system is covering up. Let's start with the story on the taxpayer funded CBC by Sarah Petz that can be summed up in the lead. "A February incident where an off-duty Winnipeg officer allegedly knocked a suspect unconscious wasn't reported to the province's police watchdog, and one criminologist says it shows how flawed oversight of law enforcement can be." There you have it. A policeman, not

Winnipeg needs a new police chief - ASAP

When did the magic die? A week ago the Winnipeg police department delivered the bad news---crime in the city is out of control. The picture painted by the numbers (for 2018) was appalling. Robberies up ten percent in  a single year.  (And that was the good news.) Property crimes were up almost 20 percent.  Total crime was 33 percent higher than the five year average. The measure of violent crime in Winnipeg had soared to a rating of 161.  Only four years earlier it stood at 116. That's a 38 percent deterioration in safety. How did it happen? How, when in 2015 the police and Winnipeg's police board announced they had discovered the magic solution to crime? "Smart Policing" they called it.    A team of crime analysts would pore through data to spot crime hot-spots and as soon as they identified a trend (car thefts, muggings, liquor store robberies) they could call in police resources to descend on the problem and nip it. The police